My head's going round a bit on the format to choose for Albion. I'm hoping someone will say something wise to help crystallise it!

Background: Albion is my celtic-themed fantasy game, a very long-term project - it got a partial, abortive release a few years ago and I'm aiming to do a proper, finished version. It's more like a traditional than an "indie" game, both in how the system works and in being fairly big.

I don't know what size the book will be. I did before: Letter. But things have moved on since then, and the waters are murkier due to possible choices of printer and sales route.

• I could go for Lulu but Letter is a poor choice now due to the cost.

• It isn't available, exactly, at Lightning Source. A nearly-Letter size is but not in hardback - an option I'd like to have.
• Letter would be the way to go if I approached Flaming Cobra. (Leaving aside questions about getting accepted.)

So that leads to questions about target audience, supplement schedules and other stuff. If aiming at the traditional market, accessed through stores, Flaming Cobra would be the way to go. However, expectations of supplement release would be different from the small press routes I've used till now: people would hope to see a regular flow of 128-page softbacks.

If I stick to the small press routes I've used till now, I've got a little bit of profile and the standard for supplements can be very laid-back: eg do short PDFs when you feel like it and collect them in print later. I've got to know the ropes a bit now. For format I'd probably pick 7x10in or 6x9in and print 'em at Lightning. Of course, this way I have to find the capital myself!

This is causing a particular problem for me, even at the stage I'm at, because (a) I tend to work direct in DTP, cos I'm weird, and (b) this is an overhaul of an existing book anyway. Makes it quite hard to separate the text and the layout, which gums the process up a bit with an indeterminate page size.

= = =

There's also the issue of how to separate player and GM information, as there's quite a strong element of discovering what's going on in the world so you don't want players to have that info in front of them. The lead options are to have two separate books, which was the plan way back, or to do an all-in-one plus a player's book (print or pdf), which I think is my favourite now.